“The Fisherman” (1778) and “The Erl-King” (1782) are Goethe’s best-known ballads of nature magic. In both, a being steps out of nature, lures a human being with promises and draws him to his death.
Seduction
The water-woman in “The Fisherman” seduces with song and an image of peace and coolness; he follows ‘half drawn, half sinking’, out of his own longing too. The Erl-King lures with games and daughters, then threatens force.
The victim
In “The Fisherman” a grown man gives in; in “The Erl-King” a child who cannot defend himself and whom his father does not believe. That makes “The Erl-King” more menacing.
Read the texts
Study this text with Goethe Academy ›
Goethe Write mode: write it yourself
- Put the texts you want to compare into the Research folder of a project.
- Write your comparison in the manuscript next to them.
- Save a snapshot before every big change and compare the snapshots side by side.
Writing a book of your own? Goethe Write gives it chapters, an outline, a timeline and characters – on the Mac, iPhone and iPad. All features ›
