Developmental edit
Before anyone corrects commas, someone has to ask whether the story works. A developmental edit does exactly that – it looks at the whole book and how it is built.
Definition
A developmental edit (also structural edit or substantive edit) is the first and broadest stage of professional editing. The editor reads the whole manuscript and comments on:
- Structure: does the story build, turn and resolve? Is the midpoint strong, is the climax earned?
- Characters: are motivations clear, does the protagonist change?
- Pacing: where does the story drag or rush?
- Point of view and voice: are they consistent? See point of view.
- For nonfiction: argument, order of chapters, gaps and repetitions.
The result is usually an editorial letter – a report of several pages – plus notes in the manuscript. The writer then revises, sometimes with a page-one rewrite.
The stages of editing
- Developmental edit – the big picture.
- Line edit – style, rhythm and clarity sentence by sentence.
- Copyedit – grammar, spelling, consistency, facts.
- Proofreading – the final check, often on galley proofs.
In German publishing, the developmental and line stages are often combined in the Lektorat, while the copyedit is called Korrektorat.
Example
Invented for this glossary, from an editorial letter:
The first message in the logbook arrives on page 90. Until then, the reader has no question to follow. Consider moving it to the first chapter and folding the backstory into later scenes.
Common mistakes
- Asking for a copyedit first. Polishing sentences in scenes that may be cut wastes time and money.
- Expecting the editor to rewrite. The editor diagnoses; the writer revises.
- Taking notes as orders. Understand the problem behind each note before choosing your solution.
Related terms
Copyedit, beta reader, page-one rewrite, galley proof.
Questions
Do I need a developmental edit before querying an agent?
It is not required. Many writers revise with beta readers instead. If you hire an editor, a developmental edit is usually the most useful stage before submission.
How is a developmental edit different from a manuscript critique?
A critique is usually a shorter report without notes in the text. A developmental edit is typically more detailed and includes comments throughout the manuscript.