Unreliable narrator
Some narrators tell us the truth. Others leave things out, bend the facts or simply don't understand what is happening. When the reader realises this, the story changes shape – that is the effect of an unreliable narrator.
Definition
An unreliable narrator is a narrator – usually in first person – whose version of events differs from what the reader gradually recognises as the truth. The term was introduced by the literary critic Wayne C. Booth in 1961.
Common kinds of unreliability:
- The liar: deliberately misleads the reader, for example to hide a crime.
- The self-deceiver: believes their own flattering or comforting version.
- The naive narrator: a child or outsider who reports accurately but misunderstands.
- The impaired narrator: memory, illness or intoxication distorts what they report.
The art lies in letting the reader notice the gap: through contradictions, other characters' reactions, or details the narrator mentions without understanding them.
Example
Invented for this glossary:
I never raised my voice at Clara. Not once in twelve years. That evening I simply explained, quite calmly, why the car keys would stay with me – and if the neighbours called the police, it was because they had always disliked us.
The narrator insists on his calm, while the police call tells the reader a different story.
Common mistakes
- The cheat twist: the narrator hides something only by withholding it from the reader with no hints at all. Readers often feel tricked rather than surprised.
- Too obvious: if the unreliability is clear from the first page, there is little to discover.
- Inconsistent logic: the narrator's distortions should follow from who they are.
- Forgetting the real story. You need to know what actually happened, even if the narrator never says it.
Related terms
Point of view, flashback, voice-over, protagonist.
In Goethe Write
To keep track of what really happened versus what the narrator claims, you can record what each character knows and when in the Plot tool's Knowledge board, and date scenes on the Timeline. See outlining in Goethe Write.
Questions
Does an unreliable narrator have to be first person?
Most are, because first person gives the narrator full control of the telling. Close third person can also be unreliable when it reflects a character's distorted view.
Should the reader find out the truth?
Usually, at least in part. The pleasure of these stories often lies in recognising the gap – either gradually or in one revealing moment.